← Back to Blog

One of the most common questions we hear at Neighborhood Necessities is: "Should I buy name brand or store brand?" The answer isn't always the same. It depends on the product, your needs, and your budget.

After years of helping Decatur families make these decisions, we've learned that sometimes name brands are worth the extra cost, and sometimes store brands deliver the same value for significantly less. Here's our honest take on when to spend and when to save.

When Name Brands Are Worth It

Laundry Detergent

Name brand laundry detergents like Tide often have more powerful stain-fighting formulas. If you deal with tough stains (kids' clothes, work uniforms, etc.), name brands can be worth the extra cost. However, for regular laundry loads, quality store brands work just fine.

Diapers

Name brand diapers like Huggies and Pampers often have better leak protection and fit. If you've had issues with leaks or your baby has sensitive skin, name brands might be worth the investment. However, many store brand diapers work equally well for most babies.

Paper Towels

Name brand paper towels like Bounty are often more absorbent and durable. If you use paper towels heavily (large families, frequent cooking, etc.), the extra absorbency can be worth it. For occasional use, store brands are usually sufficient.

When Store Brands Are Just As Good

All-Purpose Cleaner

For most cleaning tasks, store brand all-purpose cleaners work just as well as name brands. The active ingredients are usually the same, and the cleaning power is comparable. Unless you're dealing with extremely tough stains, save your money and go with store brands.

Toilet Paper

Quality store brand toilet paper is often made in the same facilities as name brands and offers similar softness and strength. Unless you have a strong preference for a specific brand's feel, store brands can save you 30-40% with no noticeable difference.

Baby Wipes

Store brand baby wipes often work just as well as name brands. The main differences are usually in texture and fragrance, not effectiveness. As long as they're alcohol-free and gentle on skin, store brands are usually a great value.

Dish Soap

Store brand dish soap often cleans just as well as name brands. The main difference is usually in fragrance and sometimes in sudsing. If you're not picky about scent, store brands are an easy way to save.

The Truth About Store Brands

Many store brands are made by the same manufacturers as name brands, just packaged differently. This is especially true for products like toilet paper, paper towels, and some cleaning supplies. The quality is often the same—you're just not paying for the brand name.

How to Decide

Here's our practical approach to deciding between name brands and store brands:

1. Start with Store Brands

Try store brands first. If they work well for your needs, you've saved money. If they don't meet your expectations, then switch to name brands.

2. Consider Your Usage

If you use a product heavily or have specific needs (tough stains, sensitive skin, etc.), name brands might be worth the extra cost. For occasional use or basic needs, store brands are usually sufficient.

3. Read the Labels

Compare ingredients and active ingredients. Often, store brands have very similar formulas to name brands. The differences are usually in fragrance, packaging, or minor formula variations.

4. Mix and Match

You don't have to choose all name brands or all store brands. Use name brands where they make a difference for you, and store brands where they work just as well. This approach can save you money while still getting the quality you need.

The Bottom Line

The best choice depends on your specific needs and budget. Here's our general guidance:

• For everyday cleaning: Store brands are usually fine and can save you 30-50%
• For tough jobs: Name brands often have more powerful formulas
• For sensitive needs: Choose what works best for you, whether name brand or store brand
• For paper products: Quality store brands are usually a great value
• For baby products: It depends on your baby's needs—try store brands first

At Neighborhood Necessities, we carry both name brands and quality store brands. We're here to help you find what works best for your needs and budget. We believe in giving you real choices, not pushing you toward one option or another.

Stop by our store on Glenwood Road or call us at (470) 366-0836. We'll help you decide what's best for your situation, whether that's name brands, store brands, or a mix of both.

Remember: The best product is the one that works for you and your budget. Don't let brand names fool you—sometimes the generic option is just as good, if not better.

← Back to Blog Shop Products